Who Does Belly End Up With in The Summer I Turned Pretty?

Quick answer: Belly ends up with Conrad Fisher — in both the book trilogy and the Prime Video series. After years of complicated feelings, a failed engagement to Jeremiah, and a life-changing reunion in Paris, Belly chooses Conrad in a moment that fans have been waiting for since the very first episode.

If you’ve been glued to your screen watching Belly Conklin navigate one of the most emotionally charged love triangles in recent TV history, you already know the gut-punch feeling of not being sure who she’s going to choose. The question of who does Belly end up with has been tearing fandoms apart since Jenny Han’s trilogy first landed on shelves back in 2009 — and it exploded all over again when the Prime Video adaptation premiered in June 2022.

Three seasons, one canceled wedding, and a whole lot of tears later, The Summer I Turned Pretty delivered its series finale on September 17, 2025 — and it was everything. Whether you’re here because you want the book spoilers, the TV ending, or a full breakdown of Belly’s complicated love life, you’ve come to the right place.

Grab your iced coffee. This is going to be good.

Who Is Belly? A Quick Summer I Turned Pretty Overview

Isabel “Belly” Conklin is the heart and soul of Jenny Han’s The Summer I Turned Pretty trilogy, published by Simon & Schuster between 2009 and 2011. The three books — The Summer I Turned Pretty, It’s Not Summer Without You, and We’ll Always Have Summer — follow Belly across several summers spent at Cousins Beach, where her mother Laurel’s lifelong best friend, Susannah Fisher, owns a beach house.

Every summer, the Conklins and the Fishers come together — and every summer, Belly finds herself caught between Susannah’s two sons: the brooding, emotionally guarded Conrad Fisher and his warm, charismatic younger brother Jeremiah Fisher.

When the Prime Video adaptation premiered on June 17, 2022, actress Lola Tung brought Belly to life with remarkable depth. Season 2 followed in July 2023, and the third and final season kicked off on July 16, 2025. The show became a cultural phenomenon, sparking heated Team Conrad vs. Team Jeremiah debates across social media, fan forums, and even college campuses.

Now that the series has wrapped, let’s break down exactly how it all played out — starting with the two brothers at the center of it all.

Who Does Belly End Up With? The Direct Answer

Belly ends up with Conrad Fisher.

This is true in both Jenny Han’s original book trilogy and the Prime Video television series. In the books, Belly and Conrad eventually marry. In the TV show, the series finale ends with Belly boarding Conrad’s train in Paris and delivering one of the most romantic confessions in recent TV history: “Conrad, I choose you, of my own free will. If there are infinite worlds, every version of me chooses you, in every one of them.”

If you’re here just for that answer — there you go. But if you want the full story of how Belly and Conrad got there (and why it took so long), keep reading.

Belly and Conrad: Their Relationship Timeline

How They Met and the Early Tension

Belly has had a crush on Conrad Fisher since she was a little girl. Every summer at Cousins Beach, she’d follow him around hoping he’d notice her — and for years, he mostly didn’t. Conrad was older, distant, and impossible to read.

In the first book — and the first season of the show — Conrad’s behavior toward Belly swings between cold indifference and intense protectiveness. He gets jealous when other boys pay attention to her, but he won’t admit why. It’s infuriating and swoony in equal measure. By the end of Book 1 (and Season 1), they finally get together — but Conrad’s emotional walls go right back up, and the relationship falls apart almost as quickly as it began.

Key Turning Points in Belly and Conrad’s Story

• Conrad catches Belly and Jeremiah kissing at the end of Book 2 / Season 2. Rather than fight for her, he tells Jeremiah it’s fine if they’re together — a lie that drives the rest of the story.
• The bachelor party confession: In Book 3 / Season 3, Conrad finds out Jeremiah cheated on Belly and confronts her about it. Overwhelmed, he finally admits he never stopped loving her — then immediately tries to walk it back.
• The Paris reunion (TV only): Conrad travels to Paris to see Belly on the eve of her 22nd birthday. They spend the day exploring the city, dance by the Seine, and Belly admits that the letters he sent were a comfort to her during the hardest months. They kiss. They have what you might call a very meaningful evening. And when Conrad leaves for a 5 a.m. train to Brussels, Belly realizes — finally, clearly — that it’s always been him.
• The train station moment: Belly races to the station. She boards his train. She finds him alone and tear-eyed. She shows him she’s wearing his infinity necklace. And she chooses him.

In the books, Belly’s journey takes a different route — she studies abroad in Spain, Conrad sends her handwritten letters every month for years, and they reunite at her college graduation. He proposes. They get married. The series ends with the words “they are infinite.”

Belly and Jeremiah: Their Relationship Timeline

Their Bond and Chemistry

Jeremiah Fisher is, by every measure, the easier choice. He’s warm, funny, and openly devoted to Belly in a way Conrad never quite managed. Where Conrad broods, Jeremiah smiles. Where Conrad pulls away, Jeremiah steps forward. Fans who fell for him weren’t wrong to do so — Jeremiah genuinely loves Belly, and their chemistry is real.

He’s been quietly in love with her while she pined for his brother, and in Book 2 / Season 2, he can’t hold it in any longer. He kisses her. She kisses him back. They fall into a two-year relationship that, at the start, feels like exactly what Belly needed.

Key Turning Points in Belly and Jeremiah’s Story

• The shift in Season 3: By We’ll Always Have Summer — and the show’s final season — Jeremiah has changed. He cheats on Belly with a sorority girl during a trip to Cabo. When Belly finds out, she slaps him across the face. He proposes as a way of proving his remorse, and she hesitantly says yes.
• The engagement chaos: Their engagement sends shockwaves through everyone — Belly’s mom Laurel refuses to attend the wedding, Conrad is devastated, and the tension at Cousins Beach becomes unbearable.
• The wedding day: In the books, Jeremiah actually shows up willing to get married — until Belly admits she still loves Conrad. When Jeremiah asks her directly, she can’t deny it. He ends things. In the TV show, the dynamic is slightly different, but the result is the same: the wedding doesn’t happen.
• Jeremiah moves on: In the TV finale, Jeremiah finds a spark with his coworker Denise — a hopeful, if bittersweet, note for a character who deserved better than being anyone’s second choice.

Conrad vs. Jeremiah: Side-by-Side Comparison

Feature	Conrad Fisher	Jeremiah Fisher
Personality	Brooding, intense, emotionally guarded	Warm, outgoing, socially at ease
Archetype	“Black cat”	“Golden retriever”
Relationship with Belly	First love, childhood crush, long-buried feelings	Best friend turned boyfriend
Biggest flaw	Emotional withdrawal, avoidance	Cheating, using the engagement to “win”
Biggest strength	Knows Belly completely and loves all of her	Easy affection, immediate comfort
Fan allegiance	Dominant (113 vs. 11 votes in a campus poll, per The Daily Cardinal, 2025)	Passionate but smaller fanbase
How he loves Belly	Quietly, intensely, and constantly	Warmly, but insecurely in Book 3
End of story	Gets the girl	Finds hope with someone new

Pros and Cons: Conrad vs. Jeremiah as Belly’s Partner

	Conrad	Jeremiah
Pros	Knows Belly on a soul-deep level; consistent underlying love; emotionally growth by Season 3/Book 3; Belly’s mom Laurel adores him	Emotionally available (early on); fun, warm, and easy to be with; genuinely kind and supportive
Cons	Years of emotional unavailability; tendency to shut down; made Belly feel invisible for too long	Cheated on Belly; used the engagement partly to compete with Conrad; tried to talk Belly out of going to Paris

Bottom line: Conrad is the harder choice that leads to the deeper love. Jeremiah is the easier choice that ultimately wasn’t built to last.

The Final Answer: How Belly Chooses Conrad

What makes Belly’s choice so powerful — in both the books and the show — is that it doesn’t happen because Conrad is perfect. It happens because Belly finally accepts that she is still the girl who has always loved him, and that girl is worth choosing.

In the TV finale, after a night with Conrad that leaves her both elated and terrified, she tries to push him away — telling him she can’t make promises, that she worries their love is just grief wrapped up in nostalgia for Susannah. Conrad refuses to let that narrative stand. “If I met you for the first time tonight, I would love you,” he tells her through tears.

When he leaves for Brussels, Belly’s internal monologue lays it all bare: “I have brown hair and brown eyes, and I will always love Conrad Fisher.” She drops everything. Runs to the train station. Boards his train. And when she finds him — alone, red-eyed, clearly devastated — she shows him the infinity necklace.

Her confession is the culmination of three seasons of longing, mistakes, and growth: “Conrad, I choose you, of my own free will. If there are infinite worlds, every version of me chooses you, in every one of them.”

The series closes with the two of them walking back into the Cousins Beach house together — the place where it all began.

Team Conrad vs. Team Jeremiah: What the Fans Think

The debate between Team Conrad and Team Jeremiah has been one of the most spirited in TV fandom over the past few years. And while Conrad clearly has more supporters, the Jeremiah camp is passionate and vocal.

According to a poll by The Daily Cardinal (2025), campus fans voted 113 to 11 in favor of Team Conrad. But that doesn’t mean Jeremiah’s fans were wrong to root for him. Many viewers saw his warmth and openness as exactly what Belly needed after years of being emotionally strung along by Conrad. His arc in Season 3, though painful, resonated with fans who’ve experienced how love and insecurity can become tangled up in each other.

The online conversation during Season 3’s final episodes was intense. Refinery29 noted a third camp entirely — “Team Belly” fans who were less interested in the love triangle and more invested in watching Belly grow into herself. Given that Lola Tung’s performance drew comparisons to iconic teen TV leads and earned praise for its nuance and emotional depth, that framing makes complete sense.

Interestingly, Jenny Han herself said publicly before Season 3 aired that the show’s ending would differ from the books — surprising fans who thought they already knew how it would end. She kept her word. The Paris setting, the train station moment, the infinity necklace — none of that is in the books. It made the finale feel fresh and genuinely surprising, even for readers who knew Conrad was the endgame.

After the finale, Han left a handwritten note teasing the future: “Maybe we’ll meet again one summer in Cousins.” A movie is currently in the works, per reports from April 2026.

So, Who Does Belly End Up With — For Good?

Conrad Fisher. Always Conrad.

The question of who does Belly end up with has been debated since 2009, and the answer has never really changed — even when the storytelling made it feel deliciously uncertain. Both the books and the TV show arrive at the same destination: Belly and Conrad are, as the books put it, infinite.

Their love story isn’t the easiest or the most straightforward. It’s the kind that takes years, wrong turns, and real heartbreak to get to. But when Belly finally says “I choose you” on that Brussels-bound train — after all of it — you believe her completely. And that’s exactly what makes it worth the wait.

---

Frequently Asked Questions